I PURITANI – REVIEW OF 2026 LIVE FROM THE MET IN HD TRANSMISSION

 Reviewed by James Karas

Vincenzo Bellini’s  I Puritani is one of the finest bel canto operas, warts and all, and the Metropolitan Opera transmitted it to theatres around the world on January 10, 2026. Musically and vocally, it is an outstanding production but the “warts” of the libretto are still there. This was the 67^th Metropolitan Opera performance of the work which gives you a good indication of its popularity. 

The last Met production was in 1976 and it was revived several times. The current staging is by Charles Edwards who brings his own ideas. He tinkers with the plot that involves the beautiful Elvira (Lisette Oropesa) who is in love with Lord Arturo during the English Civil War of the 1640’s. She is a Puritan (The Roundheads) and he is a Royalist (The Cavaliers). During the overture, Edwards shows Elvira painting Arturo’s portrait and falling in love with him. It is 1641 and the Civil War has not started yet but it is brewing. Edwards gives us a timeline on the screen to make sense of the libretto.

In the meantime, Puritan Riccardo (Ricardo José Rivera) has fallen in love with Elvira and her father wants her to marry him. Luckily her uncle Giorgio (Christian Van Horn) has convinced him to let her marry Arturo.

Lisette Oropesa as Elvira and Lawrence Brownlee as Arturo 

in Bellini's "I Puritani." Photo: Ken Howard / Met Opera

In the meantime, or eight years later, we meet Enrichetta (Eve Gigliotti) flitting on and off the stage. Arturo arrives at the camp of the enemies, for his wedding to Elvira and recognizes Enrichetta as the wife of the beheaded King Charles I. She is a prisoner of the Roundheads and he decides to save her from certain death by disguising her as Elvira and leaving the latter at the altar. 

If you sense noticeable creaking, it is not the floorboards; it is the plot. In any event Elvira goes mad, the Roundheads win, Arturo returns, Elvira regains her sanity and they all live happily evert after. You do not see I Puritani for the plot details but for the gorgeous music, astounding bel canto singing, superb sets and lighting that more than make up for the unsatisfactory libretto by Carlo Pepoli, based on the play Têtes Rondes et Cavaliers by Jacques-François Ancelot and Joseph Xavier Saintine.

You see the opera to hear the extraordinary voice of soprano Lisette Oropesa. Bellini provides melodies that demand flourishes, long lines , intricate singing that few sopranos can manage. Oropesa masters him. She is stunning throughout and especially in the Mad Scene with a full-range display of emotional depth and vocal splendor.

Tenor Lawrence Brownlee has a light, flexible and terrific tenor voice that can reach the stratosphere but sings with unmatched beauty in his arias and ensemble pieces. His Arturo is heroic, decent, in love and always vocally marvelous as he holds the long phrases, soars where necessary and is simply an aural delight.

Baritone Artur Ruciński was indisposed and baritone Ricardo José Rivera replaced him on a few hours’ notice in the role of the spurned lover Riccardo. He did excellent work and earned the respect, enthusiasm and enthusiastic applause of the audience. Well deserved.

Bass baritone Christian van Horn sang the role of Elivira’s uncle Giorgio. Van Horn exudes authority and compassion and can convince Elvira’s father to let her marry for love. Van Horn is a fine actor and a superb singer, able to handle his solo and ensemble singing with rare sonority and beauty.

Edwards makes Elvira a painter and there are numerous portraits on stage. The one that drew my attention was a huge portrait of King Charles I that Enrichetta dances with and twirls around her head and kisses affectionately. The latter made no sense but making Elvira an artist is a nice touch.

Edwards also designed the sets, featuring paneled risers that could be a legislature or a meeting hall. Tim Mitchell’s lighting design changes scenes and atmosphere brilliantly. Gabrielle Dalton’s costumes feature the classic black dresses, white collars and white hats for the women and similar black and white costumes for the men. There are exceptions for Arturo, Elvira and Enrichetta and, I assume, brilliant red for the victorious Oliver Cromwell who makes a short appearance.

Marco Armiliato conducted the Met Orchestra and Chorus in a superb performance. Bellini composed numerous pieces for the chorus that all added to a memorable production of an opera

Edwards and Armiliato, with the brilliant cast, brought out the best of I Puritani and watching it on a big theatre screen was highly enjoyable.

If you hear any creaking after seeing this production, you should check your floorboards.
 ________________________
I Puritani by Vincenzo Bellini was transmitted Live in HD from the Metropolitan Opera on January 10, 2026, at the Cineplex VIP Shops at Don Mills, 12 Marie Labatte Road, Toronto Ontario and other theatres across Canada. Encores will be shown on February 28, 2026. For more information: www.cineplex.com/events

James Karas is the Culture Editor of The Greek Press, Toronto

THE MAGIC FLUTE - REVIEW OF 2006 MET PRODUCTION STREAMED IN 2025

 Reviewed by James Karas

On December 30. 2006 The Metropolitan Opera filmed  Julie Taymor’s production of The Magic Flute for PBS. That recording was transmitted worldwide Live in HD From the Met. But on December 20, 2025. we were supposed to get the current revival of Julie Taymor’s shortened version of the opera with Paul Aplebu, Michael Samuel and Alexander Kppeczi conducted by Steven White. The Met’s program said so. 

But the one-page program that we got at Cineplex stated that we were about to see The Magic Flute that was transmitted Live on December 20, 2006. Something went wrong but I don’t know what. The broadcast on CBC radio was of the current performance with the cast noted above.

Julie Taynor has her own take of the opera with a version thar lasts only 1 hour and 50 minutes, sung in English and geared toward entertaining children as well as adults.  A highly laudable ambition.

She uses various methods of entertaining children and I don’t know if all were successful. She takes a dark view of the opera and much of the performance is done on a black background. The Three Ladies, Wendy Bryn Harmer, Kate Lindsey and Tamara Mumford are dressed in black, with white puppet heads that are worn on their heads or held in their hands.

The Queen of the Night (Erika Miklosa) has a seriously painted face (like most of the cast) and she has huge banners waved behind her. She is a remarkable figure as is Miklosa a remarkable singer. Tenor Matthew Polenzani as Tamino and soprano Ying Huand are handsome and beautiful and we see their faces clearly. The hero and heroine sing brightly and gorgeously and we root for them. 

 A scene from Mozart's "The Magic Flute." Photo: Ken Howard / Met Opera 

of the 2025 production and not the one under review.

Rene Pape is outfitted like a pagoda or some grand structure but he sings a marvelous Sarastro. Monostatos wears lots of colourful makeup, sports a big, hooked nose and is appropriately nasty but Greg Fedderly is very effective as the would-be sexual predator against our Pamina. Nathan Gunn as Papageno, is fleet of foot and superb of voice as the cowardly bird catcher. The stage is full of papier mache birds, flying bears and thunder and lightning to keep everything moving and everyone entertained and we hope that includes the youngsters.

The production is sung in English which does not mean that everything was comprehensible but I think it was appropriate. Youngsters do not need subtitles in their first or one of their first exposures to opera.

Taymor, in addition to directing, also designed the costumes and, with Michael Curry, she designed the puppets. In other words, this is a Julie Taymor production through and through.

The late James Levine conducted the Met Orchestra in the broadcast of the 2006 production which launched the rightly heralded Live in HD transmissions. It was interesting to see it in the 40th year of opera in a local movie theatre but seeing the current revival live would have been even more interesting.
_______________
The 2006 recording of The Magic Flute by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart with libretto by Emanuel Schikaneder was transmitted from the Metropolitan Opera on December 20, 2025, at the Cineplex VIP, Shops at Don Mills, 12 Marie Labatte Road, Toronto Ontario M3C 0H9 and other theatres. For more information including encores see: www.cineplex.com/events

James Karas is the Senior Editor, Culture of The Geek Press, Toronto.